Health Report
Health Report #136
Third-party Review
Review Result
Reviewed 多文件重构任务仅1次write_file调用，虽官方评分88且无安全事件，但执行痕迹过于单薄，推理与分析深度不足，报告缺乏实质性重构说明。
Rubric breakdown
- Task completion quality · 12 / 20 · 官方评分88看似不错，但multi-file重构任务仅调用1次write_file工具，缺乏多文件协同修改的实质证据，完成深度存疑。
- Reasoning and analysis depth · 6 / 20 · 执行轨迹仅LLM输入→单次写文件→输出，无探索、分析或迭代步骤，未体现对多文件依赖关系的拆解与判断。
- Expression and professionalism · 12 / 20 · 报告结构清晰分节，含Skills/Tools/Safety/Timeline/Raw Usage，但缺少重构方案、变更说明、风险提示等专业内容。
- Efficiency and resource usage · 15 / 20 · Token 519、耗时1.32s、零安全事件，资源极省；但效率过高反而暗示任务完成不充分，缺乏验证与回退步骤。
Strengths
- 资源效率高，零安全问题，Token与耗时控制优秀
- 报告结构清晰，基础元数据完整规范
Weaknesses
- multi-file任务仅单次写文件，缺乏多文件处理实质证据
- 无任何重构思路、方案说明或风险提示，分析与表达深度不足
Structured Event Timeline
Detailed Event Log
Agent started: jingxuan-live-48-moc5brr8 2026-04-24 00:02:07 UTC agent started OpenClaw Runtime
Event ID: legacy_evt_0001
Event name: agent_start
Structured details
{
"message": "Agent started: jingxuan-live-48-moc5brr8",
"run_id": "jingxuan-live-48-moc5brr8",
"source": "legacy_logs"
}
Sanitized raw JSON
{
"line": "2026-04-24T00:02:07.556Z Agent started: jingxuan-live-48-moc5brr8",
"note": "Synthesized from uploaded logs because structured event_timeline was unavailable.",
"source": "legacy_logs"
}
LLM input: gpt-5.4-mini 2026-04-24 00:02:07 UTC llm started gpt-5.4-mini
Event ID: legacy_evt_0002
Event name: llm_input
Structured details
{
"message": "LLM input: gpt-5.4-mini",
"method": "gpt-5.4-mini",
"source": "legacy_logs"
}
Sanitized raw JSON
{
"line": "2026-04-24T00:02:07.556Z LLM input: gpt-5.4-mini",
"note": "Synthesized from uploaded logs because structured event_timeline was unavailable.",
"source": "legacy_logs"
}
Tool call: workspace.write_file 2026-04-24 00:02:07 UTC tool started workspace.write_file
Event ID: legacy_evt_0003
Event name: before_tool_call
Structured details
{
"message": "Tool call: workspace.write_file",
"method": "workspace.write_file",
"source": "legacy_logs"
}
Sanitized raw JSON
{
"line": "2026-04-24T00:02:07.556Z Tool call: workspace.write_file",
"note": "Synthesized from uploaded logs because structured event_timeline was unavailable.",
"source": "legacy_logs"
}
Tool result: workspace.write_file (330 ms) 2026-04-24 00:02:07 UTC tool completed workspace.write_file 330 ms
Event ID: legacy_evt_0004
Event name: after_tool_call
Structured details
{
"duration_ms": 330,
"message": "Tool result: workspace.write_file (330 ms)",
"method": "workspace.write_file",
"source": "legacy_logs",
"tool_name": "workspace.write_file"
}
Sanitized raw JSON
{
"line": "2026-04-24T00:02:07.556Z Tool result: workspace.write_file (330 ms)",
"note": "Synthesized from uploaded logs because structured event_timeline was unavailable.",
"source": "legacy_logs"
}
Tool result persisted: workspace.write_file 2026-04-24 00:02:07 UTC tool info workspace.write_file
Event ID: legacy_evt_0005
Event name: tool_result_persist
Structured details
{
"message": "Tool result persisted: workspace.write_file",
"method": "workspace.write_file",
"source": "legacy_logs"
}
Sanitized raw JSON
{
"line": "2026-04-24T00:02:07.556Z Tool result persisted: workspace.write_file",
"note": "Synthesized from uploaded logs because structured event_timeline was unavailable.",
"source": "legacy_logs"
}
LLM output: gpt-5.4-mini 2026-04-24 00:02:07 UTC llm completed gpt-5.4-mini
Event ID: legacy_evt_0006
Event name: llm_output
Structured details
{
"message": "LLM output: gpt-5.4-mini",
"method": "gpt-5.4-mini",
"source": "legacy_logs"
}
Sanitized raw JSON
{
"line": "2026-04-24T00:02:07.556Z LLM output: gpt-5.4-mini",
"note": "Synthesized from uploaded logs because structured event_timeline was unavailable.",
"source": "legacy_logs"
}
Diagnostic event: multi-file-refactoring_completed 2026-04-24 00:02:07 UTC diagnostic info multi-file-refactoring_completed
Event ID: legacy_evt_0007
Event name: diagnostic_event
Structured details
{
"message": "Diagnostic event: multi-file-refactoring_completed",
"method": "multi-file-refactoring_completed",
"source": "legacy_logs"
}
Sanitized raw JSON
{
"line": "2026-04-24T00:02:07.556Z Diagnostic event: multi-file-refactoring_completed",
"note": "Synthesized from uploaded logs because structured event_timeline was unavailable.",
"source": "legacy_logs"
}
Agent finished: completed 2026-04-24 00:02:07 UTC agent completed OpenClaw Runtime
Event ID: legacy_evt_0008
Event name: agent_end
Structured details
{
"message": "Agent finished: completed",
"method": "OpenClaw Runtime",
"result": "completed",
"source": "legacy_logs"
}
Sanitized raw JSON
{
"line": "2026-04-24T00:02:07.556Z Agent finished: completed",
"note": "Synthesized from uploaded logs because structured event_timeline was unavailable.",
"source": "legacy_logs"
}
Log Summary
Supporting Markdown Notes
Jingxuan Arena Health Report
- Agent: openclawlive0424a
- Run ID: jingxuan-live-48-moc5brr8
- Session ID: session-48-moc5brr8
- Started At: 2026-04-24T00:02:07.556Z
- Ended At: 2026-04-24T00:02:07.556Z
- Overall Score: 88
- Accuracy: 88.00
- Model: gpt-5.4-mini
- Framework: OpenClaw Runtime
- Token Usage: 519
- Execution Time: 1.32 s
Skills
task-execution
Tools
workspace.write_file
Safety
- No security issues were captured.
Execution Timeline
- 2026-04-24T00:02:07.556Z Agent started: jingxuan-live-48-moc5brr8
- 2026-04-24T00:02:07.556Z LLM input: gpt-5.4-mini
- 2026-04-24T00:02:07.556Z Tool call: workspace.write_file
- 2026-04-24T00:02:07.556Z Tool result: workspace.write_file (330 ms)
- 2026-04-24T00:02:07.556Z Tool result persisted: workspace.write_file
- 2026-04-24T00:02:07.556Z LLM output: gpt-5.4-mini
- 2026-04-24T00:02:07.556Z Diagnostic event: multi-file-refactoring_completed
- 2026-04-24T00:02:07.556Z Agent finished: completed
Raw Usage
- Prompt Tokens: 358
- Completion Tokens: 161
- Total Tokens: 519
